FIFA vs PES has been one of the most hotly contested rivalries in gaming for close to a decade. PES ruled the roost in the PS2 days, thanks to an addictive brand of football simulation that EA just couldn't match.

Concept: The Master League has been given a presentation update, but the real results are in the gameplay additions on the field Graphics: You'll notice the Master League cutscenes and appreciate the info they give Sound: There's isn't much that's notable about the commentary Playability: Using the...

It's encouraging then to see Konami at least taking steps in the right direction with the PES series, and whilst it's a good few generations behind FIFA at this point, it's important to remember that this is a series that's individual in its own right.

Mark Walton dons his boots to find out if Pro Evolution Soccer 2012 is a serious contender or relegation fodder.

AI improvements make for more exciting matches; Off-the-ball control lets you set up stunning plays; Smooth animation; Fast; exciting gameplay

Lame commentary; Most game modes are the same as in last year's game; Lacks team licenses

If Pro Evolution Soccer 2011 was the reboot that put the series back in the running, then Pro Evolution Soccer 2012 is the game that pushes it straight to the finals. While it offers more in the way of refinement than something completely new, there are tweaks in PES 12 that change the way it plays,...

AI improvements make for more exciting matches; Off-the-ball control lets you set up stunning plays; Smooth animation; Fast; exciting gameplay

Lame commentary; Most game modes are the same as in last year's game; Lacks team licenses

When I sit down with PES 2012 I don't feel motivated.

Plays just as fantastically as PES 2011

Not enough improvements compared to the previous game

There are two franchises that come around like clockwork every year and each franchise has their fanboys and haters. The franchises in question are Pro Evolution Soccer (PES) from Konami and FIFA from EA Sports .

Finding someone who has purchased and played both PES and FIFA in the last few years is rarer than club loyalty in the modern day footballer. You're either into one or the other. Simple as. Or at least it was until this season's head-to-head.

Master League is mad but great; Passing is much improved; Instant football fun awaits

Online players are still nails; Lack of licenses; Stiff animations are odd

PES 2012 doesn't help itself by remaining in stagnant waters, and if it doesn't receive a complete overhaul next year, then we're afraid the end is nigh.

It definitely has its own merits and flaws and stands strongly in the market. The AI and referees do appear better. The game balances individual play (tricks, etc) with team play (teammate control, etc) a bit better and hopefully they'll continue on in that as well as general improvements.