I loved the last 2, thought they did a great job on the PC, but this one, looks, plays, sounds, feels just like one of these older versions. I was expecting greatness, instead got something recycled to make a quick buck, but I think this has also ruined their reputation.

What is it about shiny new loot that makes action role-playing games so enthralling? There's something perpetually rewarding about seeing a heroic warrior graduate from lowly rags and a rusty sword to gleaming gold armor and a katana so sharp you can lop a cyclops' head with it in a single swipe.

Smooth flow of loot keeps you pressing forward; Your choices steer certain story elements; Simple but entertaining combat for up to four players

A fraction of the length of previous Dungeon Siege games; Absurd co-op limitations; The camera can be a pain

I don't know why this game sold so few copies, because it's one of the greatest action RPGs I've played this gen. Sure the game's graphics are poor, but the plot is awesome (even more considering story in these kind of games) and the dialog choices really add depth to the game.

Good...

Picked it up very cheap a few weeks ago. I love this game. Played it single player with "Treasures of the Sun" DLC too. Very good story and attention to detail. Didn't find one bug while playing it either. I cannot understand why there's so much hate?

This game is so unfairly underated all because of suckish gamers. The fact is, its a must have game and it is that fun. I can prove that this game is awesome because I have beaten it and I still can't get enough.

Unfortunately there are not many, good local co-op games out there for the PS3 (probably because Sony figures most peeps prefer multiplier online) but this one goes a long way in making up for that particular failure.

If, like us, you're still yearning for the days when games like this were released more regularly, Dungeon Siege III scratches all the right itches, and you should definitely grab it soon.

Scripted story; well-thought-out characters

Limited customization; no 4-player local

I have a signature move in co-op action RPG Dungeon Siege III. How many games can I say that for? Basically none. What I like to do in Dungeon Siege III is wait until there's only one monster left to deal with.

Firstly, it's not made by the original team that crafted the marvellous Dungeon Siege and Dungeon Siege 2. Chris Taylor and his Gas Powered Games team sat this one out and handed the reigns over to veteran RPG sequel creators Obsidian Entertainment, responsible for follow-ups to Neverwinter Nights,...