I also own a bottle of this exact product purchased from Macy's and there's a bit of a difference in the scents. This one is a little more alchol-ish for lack of a better term as if it was watered down. Also, sprayer is a little flimsy leading me to think knock off.

My girlfriend helped me pick this one out. I agreed with her choice this time. I'm not a scent expert so all I can say is it smells good without being overpowering. However, last night she asked me why I haven't been wearing the new cologne I bought 3 weeks ago. I've been wearing it everyday.

Clean & Fresh, Great Smell, Not Overpowering

Doesn't Hold; Pricey / Poor Value

Opens with grapefruit and a little of coriander. After some minutes there's a light cardamom note with ginger and then joins the tobacco and amber. I smell a great ambery tobacco note in the late drydown. It's indeed a good scent, but lacks in terms of longevity and projection - romantic skin scent.

Bought this as a Valentine's gift for my husband. It smells very nice and seems that the scent lasts a while.

Dolce & Gabbana The One is one of the best mens perfumes in the market. It is a must have, However, it has quite a subtle projection. People have to be close to you for them to be able to smell it. It is a great fragrance for taking your girlfriend out to dinner, movie or theater.

I brought this product a month ago, I use it everyday because the nice fragrance last all day and would recommend it to anyone.

I'm in love with this fragrance, excellent smell not overpowering. One of the best cologne's out in the market right now. Could possibly be an instant classic.

Clean & Fresh; Great Smell; Great Value; Long-Lasting; Not Overpowering; Sexy

Really sensual type fragrance. Seems to sit close to the skin and does not project that well. Best in a date setting as it draws who you're with in closer. Definitely not a clubby type fragrance.

Great Smell; Sensual; Sexy

Too Expensive

Drives the women wild. Long lasting as i spray it in the morning and at night people still give me props. Just be careful not to spray too much as its very strong. 1-2spays is all you need. Pricey but worth every penney. Enjoy!!!

My boyfriend uses this daily since I first bought it for him. I could sniff him constantly and never get tired of the smell.

Clean & Fresh, Draws Compliments, Great Smell, Great Value, Long-Lasting, Sensual, Sexy