I believe I got mine in 2006 or 2007 and it has never disappointed. The f4 works for most outdoor use and it is a lens you can carry easily compared to the 2.8 with foot. The amazing quality really showed when I used it with my now retired film body, but also shows when my 17-85 is at telephoto and...
Amazing image quality and image stabilization
No weaknesses; Nicking it on price would not be fair because the big white Canon lenses are top tier and it seems like they spare nothing to make them